ICICI BankHDFC BankAxis BankNet Interest MarginBanking Sector

One Rate Cycle, Three Banks: Why ICICI Rose While HDFC and Axis Got Sold

Profile picture of Prateek Goel
Prateek Goel · INH00002639026 Jul 2026 · 3 min read · Updated 26 Jul 2026, 02:39 am
One Rate Cycle, Three Banks: Why ICICI Rose While HDFC and Axis Got Sold

Here is a puzzle from the last ten days. Three large private banks reported June-quarter results. All three grew profits. One stock rose, two got hammered. If you can explain why, you understand bank investing better than most people trading these names.

The scorecard first. HDFC Bank grew profit about 5% to roughly Rs 19,060 crore, and the stock was sold hard through the week. Axis Bank grew profit a much stronger 23% to about Rs 7,114 crore — and fell over 5% the very next session, with analysts cutting estimates. ICICI Bank grew profit about 16% to roughly Rs 14,805 crore, and it was among the gainers on days the Bank Nifty itself was falling.

Profit growth clearly is not the answer. The answer is margin.

A bank's core business is simple: borrow money from depositors at one rate, lend it out at a higher rate, live on the gap. That gap, expressed as a percentage of lending assets, is the net interest margin. When rates in the economy fall, loans reprice downward quickly — especially loans linked to external benchmarks — while deposits reprice slowly, because the bank is stuck paying the rates it promised on older fixed deposits. The gap compresses. That is the squeeze this entire results season is about.

Now look at the same three banks through that lens. HDFC Bank's margin slipped to 3.26%, the lowest in its recorded history. Axis Bank's fell to around 3.46% from 3.73% a year ago — a big drop in banking terms, and the real reason a 23% profit jump was greeted with a 5% price cut. ICICI Bank's margin came in around 4.36%, higher than both the previous quarter and the same quarter last year, alongside loan growth near 20% and bad loans shrinking as a share of the book.

Same economy. Same rate cycle. One bank expanded the gap while its two biggest rivals watched theirs shrink. How? Broadly, it comes down to the mix — what kinds of loans a bank writes, how fast its old deposits roll over to cheaper rates, and how much high-cost borrowing it carries. ICICI's book is currently repricing in its favour. HDFC Bank is still digesting the expensive borrowings it inherited from the merger with its parent. Axis is paying up for deposits to fund growth.

The lesson travels beyond these three names. In banking, the profit headline is the past; the margin is the future. Profit this quarter can be dressed up by one-off treasury gains or lower provisioning. The margin tells you what the core machine will earn next quarter and the one after. That is why the market ignored a 23% profit jump and traded the margin instead. The market is not always right, but it is usually reading a different line of the results than the one in the newspaper headline.

None of this makes ICICI a buy or the other two a sell — a compressed margin can recover as deposits reprice, and today's winner is tomorrow's expensive stock. What it does give you is the right question. When the next bank result crosses your screen this week, skip the profit number and find the margin, its direction, and management's explanation. Know what you own, and know why you own it — and if what you own is a bank, what you own is a margin.

Prepared by the ETH Research Desk. Prateek Goel is a SEBI-Registered Research Analyst (Reg. No. INH000026390). This is research and market commentary, not investment advice.