Three Numbers From This Earnings Season That Lied To You
Every quarter, a wave of profit numbers gets reported, and every quarter, most of them get repeated exactly as reported, without much scrutiny, because a big percentage sounds impressive and impressive is easy to share. Punjab National Bank just told the market its profit jumped 214%. On the surface, that reads like one of the best results of the entire earnings season. It is also, once you look one layer deeper, almost meaningless as a measure of how the bank actually performed.
This is not really a story about 1 bank. It is a story about 3 specific ways a profit number can technically be true and still tell you almost nothing useful, all drawn from real results this quarter, and a simple method you can use yourself the next time a headline number looks a little too good.
None of these three distortions involve anything close to fraud, and that is precisely what makes them worth understanding rather than dismissing. A company or a bank reporting a technically accurate number that happens to create a misleading impression is not breaking any rule, and it is not unique to Indian markets either. It is simply what happens when a single summary figure, profit, gets asked to represent something as complicated as an entire quarter of business activity. The problem is not the number itself, it is the habit of stopping at the number instead of asking what produced it, a habit that gets more costly every year as more people manage their own money directly rather than through a professional who might already be asking these questions on their behalf.
The first distortion is concentration, and it hides in plain sight inside the market's own favourite statistic. Nifty 50 companies grew combined profit 18% this quarter, the fastest pace in 10 quarters, and most coverage of the earnings season led with exactly that number. What most coverage did not lead with is that nearly 60% of that entire increase came from just 5 companies, names like Reliance, ONGC, and Hindalco. Meanwhile, across a much broader sample of more than 800 companies tracked by the rating agency ICRA, the average operating profit margin actually shrank by more than 2% points over the same period. Put those 2 facts side by side and a very different picture appears. The aggregate number went up because a handful of large, mostly commodity linked businesses had an exceptional quarter, not because Indian companies broadly got more profitable. The fix for this distortion is a simple habit. Whenever you see an aggregate growth number, ask how many individual companies actually grew, not just how large the total number is, because 5 loud winners can comfortably drown out a much larger, quieter group of companies that did not improve at all.
The second distortion is what happens when a profit number moves for reasons that have nothing to do with the underlying business getting better or worse, and banks are a particularly clean place to see it, because banks report 2 very different numbers every quarter that usually move together and occasionally do not. Punjab National Bank's headline profit, again, rose 214%. Its net interest income, the actual interest it earned on loans after paying interest on deposits, the number that most directly reflects whether the core lending business is growing, rose just over 2%. Almost the entire gap between those 2 numbers came from the bank setting aside far less money than usual for potential bad loans and paying less tax, both of which flow straight through to reported profit without reflecting a single rupee of new business actually written.
Interestingly, the same kind of distortion also runs in the opposite direction elsewhere in the same sector. Bank of Baroda reported profit falling nearly 72% this quarter, which sounds like a genuinely bad result, until you notice the bank took a 1 time charge of over 5,600 crore related to a legal settlement. Strip that single item out and the bank's adjusted profit was actually up around 22%. One distortion made an ordinary quarter look spectacular. The other made a genuinely decent quarter look disastrous. The fix here is also simple, look past the single bottom line profit number to the core number underneath it, for a bank that means net interest income, and ask whether anything unusual, a provision swing, a tax item, a 1 time settlement, explains the gap.
The third distortion shows up specifically in commodity businesses, and it is probably the easiest 1 to fall for, because the company itself is not hiding anything, the growth is completely real, it just is not coming from where you would assume. Hindustan Zinc grew profit 145% this quarter, with revenue up 77% and operating profit up over 100%. That is an extraordinary set of numbers by almost any standard. The company's own reporting, however, shows exactly where that growth came from, and it was overwhelmingly prices. Silver prices more than doubled over the year, and zinc prices also rose meaningfully, and out of every rupee of additional operating profit the company generated, only around 7 paise came from actually selling more metal. The rest came from the same tonnes of metal simply being worth more in the market than they were a year earlier.
There is nothing dishonest about that, commodity companies are supposed to benefit when the price of what they produce rises, but it does mean the 145% number tells you almost nothing about whether the company is being better run, gaining market share, or expanding more efficiently than before. It tells you what happened to silver and zinc prices, mostly. The fix for this 1 is to separate volume growth from price growth whenever a commodity company reports a large profit jump, because the 2 have very different implications for whether that growth is likely to repeat. A company that grows because it sold more tends to keep growing steadily. A company that grows because a metal price moved tends to give a large part of that growth straight back the moment the price moves the other way, and commodity prices, almost by definition, eventually move the other way.
| Headline Number | What It Suggests | What Actually Explains It |
|---|---|---|
| PNB, PAT +214% | Best bank result of the season | Core lending income (NII) grew just 2.1%; the rest was lower provisions and tax |
| Bank of Baroda, PAT –72% | A disastrous quarter | A one time ₹5,680 cr legal charge; adjusted PAT was actually up about 22% |
| Hindustan Zinc, PAT +145% | Exceptional operating performance | About 93% of the increase came from silver and zinc prices, not from selling more metal |
Put all 3 together and a genuinely useful checklist emerges, 1 that takes about 30 seconds to run against any headline profit number you come across. First, is this an aggregate number, and if so, how many individual companies actually contributed to it. Second, for a bank or lender specifically, did the core income number move anywhere near as much as the reported profit number, and if not, why. Third, for a commodity business, how much of the growth came from selling more versus the market simply paying more for the same volume. None of these questions require access to expensive data terminals or professional research tools. Every 1 of them can be answered from the same results announcement that produced the headline number in the first place, usually within a few pages of it.
The broader point is not that Indian companies are hiding anything sinister this earnings season, most of what is being reported is entirely accurate as stated. The point is that accurate and meaningful are not the same thing, and the gap between them is exactly where a slightly more careful read of the same public numbers starts to matter. The 3 examples here happened to be a bank, a metals company, and the market aggregate itself, but the underlying habit, checking breadth, checking the core number under the headline number, and separating price from volume, applies to essentially every sector and every earnings season that follows this 1.