Not Every Stock Is a Hero: Why I Put Every Stock in a Box Before I Buy It
Pujara will not hit 40 off 12 balls
Imagine sending Cheteshwar Pujara out in the 19th over of a T20 chase and getting angry when he blocks three balls in a row. That is not Pujara failing. That is you failing as a captain, because you gave a Test match anchor a finisher's job.
I made this exact mistake with stocks when I started out. I would buy a big, boring, well respected company and expect it to double in a year like the stock everyone was talking about on Twitter. When it moved 8% in twelve months, I felt cheated. When I bought a hot momentum stock, I held it like a fixed deposit and watched it give back everything. The stocks were fine. My expectations were wrong.
Today, before I buy anything, I ask one question first: what role is this stock playing? Bollywood understands this better than most investors. You cast Pankaj Tripathi as Kaleen Bhaiya, not as the six pack hero jumping out of a helicopter. A great actor in the wrong role still gives you a flop.
Why I put every stock in a box first
A category is not a label for fun. It tells me three things before I put in a single rupee: how fast the stock can realistically move, how long I should be willing to hold it, and what I need to watch to know the story is still intact.
A fast growing leader and a steel company can both go up 30% this year, but for completely different reasons. If I judge them with the same yardstick, I will sell the wrong one at the wrong time. So I sort every stock into one of six roles: market leaders, top competitors, institutional favourites, turnarounds, cyclicals, and the ones I avoid, past leaders and laggards. Here is how I think about each one.
1. Market leaders: the superstar in his prime
This is Shah Rukh Khan in the 90s. Every Friday release is an event. A market leader is usually number one, two, or three in its industry by sales and profits, it is taking market share, and its earnings are growing fast, often 20% or more a year. Think of how Bajaj Finance dominated consumer lending through the 2010s, or how Trent kept rolling out Zudio stores in town after town. When a company has a formula that works in one store and can copy paste it into a thousand more, earnings can compound for years.
The funny part is that most people never buy these stocks, because they always look expensive. They are the first to make new highs when the market recovers, and that strength scares people off. I have learned that a fast grower trading at a high P/E is often cheaper than it looks, because the earnings catch up with the price.
What I expect: the biggest moves in the portfolio, but also sharp falls if growth slows even a little. These stocks live and die by earnings. One quarter of disappointment and the market punishes them hard, so I track every result.
2. Top competitors: Dravid in Sachin's era
For years, Rahul Dravid batted in Sachin Tendulkar's shadow. Fewer headlines, but on many tours he was the one who actually won India the match. Top competitors are the number two or three player in a fast growing industry. They may not be the best company in the space, but they are in the right place at the right time.
Sometimes the challenger runs while the leader rests. For a stretch of the early 2020s, HDFC Bank, the undisputed leader in private banking, went mostly sideways while ICICI Bank kept climbing. Anyone who only watched the leader missed it.
What I expect: strong moves, usually a little smaller than the leader's, and occasionally a full takeover of the top spot. That is why I always track the top two or three names in any sector I like, not just number one.
3. Institutional favourites: Amitabh Bachchan today
Today Mr Bachchan is respected, dependable, and everywhere. You know exactly what you are getting. But nobody expects a Zanjeer level shock from him anymore. Institutional favourites are the same: mature blue chips like Hindustan Unilever, Asian Paints, or the large private banks. Clean balance sheets, steady dividends, and every mutual fund in the country already owns them.
That last point is the catch. When everyone already knows the story and already owns the stock, there is very little surprise left to push the price up fast. Earnings tend to grow in the low to mid teens, and HUL, for example, spent years moving mostly sideways even though the business kept doing fine.
What I expect: stability, slow compounding, and good recoveries after a big market fall. What I do not expect is a multibagger in two years. If that is what I want, this is the wrong cast.
4. Turnarounds: the Chak De India team
A women's hockey team nobody believed in, a coach with a tarnished name, and then a World Cup win. Turnarounds are companies the market had written off that suddenly start fixing themselves. Tata Motors around 2020 is the example I keep coming back to. Losses, heavy debt, and a lot of people calling it dead money. Then Jaguar Land Rover recovered, the domestic car business found its feet, debt came down, and the stock rose several times over in the years that followed.
The trap is buying on hope. I want proof in the numbers first: at least two quarters of sharply higher earnings, margins recovering, and growth that comes from more sales rather than just cost cutting. I also check how much debt and cash the company has, because a turnaround that runs out of money before it turns is just a slow crash.
What I expect: explosive moves once the market believes the story, but more volatility and more failures than any other category. If the next result comes in worse than expected, I do not wait around.
5. Cyclicals: Bhuvi under cloudy skies
Give Bhuvneshwar Kumar an overcast morning in England and a new ball, and he is unplayable. Put him on a flat road in the subcontinent at the death, and it is a different story. The skill did not change. The conditions did. Cyclical stocks like steel, cement, metals, chemicals, and auto makers work the same way. Their profits depend on the economy and on commodity prices, not just on how well they are run.
This category broke my brain when I first understood it, because the usual rule flips. A cyclical looks cheapest, with a low P/E and record profits and great news everywhere, right near the top of its cycle. It looks expensive, with a high P/E, falling earnings, dividend cuts, and nothing but bad news, near the bottom. Buying a steel stock because "the P/E is only 5" can be the most expensive decision you make.
What I expect: big moves in both directions, tied to the cycle. I hold them for the upswing, not forever, and I watch prices, inventories, and demand more closely than the P/E.
6. Past leaders and laggards: the roles I avoid
Rajesh Khanna gave India something like fifteen hits in a row. Then Amitabh arrived, the audience moved on, and the magic never fully came back. Past leaders are stocks that were the heroes of the last bull market. Remember the infra and power names everyone loved in 2007? Many of them took more than a decade just to get back to their old highs, and some never did. The story that made them great was already in the price.
Laggards are the lookalike who gets cast because he is cheaper than the original. They sit in the same sector as the leader but grow slower, earn less, and move less. People buy them because they "have not run up yet" or because the P/E is lower. There is almost always a reason a stock is cheap, and most of the time the expensive leader turns out to be the better deal.
What I expect: short bursts of catch up rallies at best, and a lot of dead time. I would rather pay up for the real thing.
Roles change, so I recast often
No stock keeps one role forever. Suzlon was a superstar in 2007, a past leader that fell more than 90% after that, and then one of the biggest turnaround stories of 2023 and 2024. Today's market leader can become tomorrow's institutional favourite once everyone owns it. So every time a company reports results, I ask again whether the role has changed, and whether my expectations should change with it.
Here is the cheat sheet I keep in my head.
| Category | Its casting | What I expect | What I watch |
|---|---|---|---|
| Market leader | SRK in his prime | The biggest moves, sharp falls if growth slows | Every quarterly result and market share |
| Top competitor | Dravid next to Sachin | Strong moves, sometimes overtakes the leader | Gap with the leader on growth and margins |
| Institutional favourite | Amitabh today | Slow, steady compounding | Valuation and dividend growth |
| Turnaround | Chak De! India | Explosive if real, many failures | Two strong quarters, debt, cash |
| Cyclical | Bhuvi under cloudy skies | Big swings with the cycle | Commodity prices, demand, inventories |
| Past leader or laggard | The faded star or the lookalike | Long dead periods | Mostly a reason to avoid |
The next time a stock "disappoints" you, ask yourself whether the stock failed, or whether you cast it in the wrong role. I would love to know which category most of your portfolio sits in right now.
The companies named here are examples for learning, not recommendations to buy or sell.